Legal Parameters of Placement of Parents in Nursing Homes as Neglect
Main Article Content
Abstract
Background. The placement of the elderly in nursing homes is still often perceived as a form of neglect, although positive law has not made such an act an automatic offense. The difference between social judgment and legal measures has led to the lack of clear parameters to determine when placement in a nursing home is still an exercise of family obligations and when it turns into neglect.
Purpose. This study aims to analyze the legal position of parental placement in nursing homes and formulate the boundary between moral obligations, family legal obligations, and neglect based on Indonesian positive laws through the theory of H.L.A. Hart.
Method. This research uses normative legal research methods with a legislative approach and a conceptual approach. The analysis was carried out qualitatively through the interpretation of laws and regulations, legal doctrines, and the theory of H.L.A. Hart as the basis of the analysis.
Results. The results showed that the measure of neglect lies in the neglect of the obligation to provide life, care, maintenance, and attention to the elderly who need help, not in the location where they live. Parental placement in a nursing home remains legal as long as the family continues to fulfill legal responsibilities, maintain relationships, supervise treatment, and ensure all parental needs are met. On the other hand, neglect only occurs when the family releases these legal obligations so that the basic needs of the parents are no longer met.
Conclusion. This research offers legal parameters that clearly distinguish between moral obligations, family obligations, and neglect, thus providing certainty in the application of laws related to the care of elderly parents.
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
References
Abdi, Syafral, et.al. 2020. A Review of Islamic Law on Parental Care by Children at the Tresna Werdha Sabai Nan Aluih Sicincin Social Home, Padang Pariaman Regency, Al-Ahkam Journal, Volume 21 Number 1, pages 169-180.
Andri, Gusti Yosi, et.al, 2024. Marriage legalization: Preserving the customary marriage tradition of the ethnic Chinese community in Cirebon City, Interdisciplinary Social Studies, Volume 4 Number 1, pages 10-20.
Alamsyah, Muhammad Nur, 2025. The Inclusion of Heirs Clauses in Credit Agreements Attributed to Personality Principles, Volume 3 Number 2, pages 24-39.
Aprilia, Annisa, et.al. 2022. Children's Obligations and Maintenance Rights Against Neglect of Elderly Parents, Al-Qisthas Journal, Volume 13 Number 2, pages 21-35.
Arief, Hanafi. 2017. Domestic Crimes, Lex Publica Journal, Volume 4 Number 1, pages 723-738.
Azhari, Doni., et.al, 2024. Legal Sociology, Indonesian Science Ambassador, Sidoarjo.
Bakung, Dolot Alhasni, et.al. 2022. Children's Responsibility to Elderly Parents (Elderly (Elderly)) in Kaaruyaan Village, Manangguu District, Gorontalo Regency, Nusantara: Journal of Community Service, Volume 2 Number 3, pages 142-155.
Batmomolin, Agnes, et.al., 2025. Elderly Problems, Indo Library Media, Cilacap.
Bello, Peter CKL. 2014. The Relationship between Law and Morality according to H.L.A. Hart, Journal of Law and Development, Volume 44 Number 3, pages 373-386.
Bello, Peter CKL. 2025. Punishment and Responsibility, Journal of Gevangenen Corrections, Volume 1 Number 1, pages 1-21.
Efendi, Aan, et.al., 2024. The Procedural Law of State Administrative Courts As The Rule of Adjudication: Exploring Hart's Theory, Journal of the Legal Arena, Volume 17 Number 1, pages 190-209.
Hart, H.L.A., 1994. The Concept of Law, 2nd Edition, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Hengki, Muhammad Rizqi, et.al. 2026. Capita of Criminal Law Selectivity (Actual Issues in Law No. 1 of 2023 concerning the Criminal Code). Media Sains Indonesia, Bandung.
Abraham, Johnny. 2005. Theory and Method of Normative Law Research, Bayumedia, Malang.
Juita, Dewi Rika. 2022. The Role of the Family in Caring for the Elderly, Al-Mada Journal, Volume 5 Number 2, pages 206-219.
Kusuma, Eri Hendro, 2017. The Relationship Between Morality and Religion and Law, Journal of Pancasila and Citizenship Education, Volume 28 Number 2, pages 96-104.
Latipulhayat, Atip. 2017. Khazanah Hart, Padjadjaran Journal of Legal Science, Volume 3 Number 3, pages 655-666.
Listari, et.al., 2023, Special Review of Child Support to Parents (Review of Positive and Comparative Legal Aspects of Islamic Law), Al Gharra: Journal of Islamic Law and Law, Volume 3 Number 1, pages 37-44.
Liswandi, et.al., 2024, Assistance for the Elderly at Adinda Mulia Bahagia Nursing Home, Jurnal Abdimas PLJ, Volume 4 Number 2, pages 72-85.
Lubis, Sifyan, Domestic Violence (Domestic Violence), Legal Articles, https://jdih.sukoharjokab.go.id/berita/detail/kdrt-kekerasan-dalam-rumah-tangga, accessed June 25, 2026, at 16.01 WIB.
Luthan, Salman, 2012. Legal and Moral Dialectics in the Perspective of Legal Philosophy, Journal of Law Ius Quia Iustum, Volume 19 Number 4, pages 506-523.
Mardani, 2025. Legal Research Methodology & Publication of Legal Articles in Scientific Journals. Refika Aditama, Bandung.
Mertokusumo, Sudikno, 2004. The Discovery of the Law of an Introduction, Liberty, Yogyakarta.
Miswardi, et.al., 2021. Ethics, Morals, and Law Enforcement, Tower of Knowledge, Volume 15 Number 2, pages 150-162.
Muammar, 2024. Quo Vadis Dignified Law Enforcement: Criticism of Law Enforcement Based on the Stigma of No Viral No Justice, Pamali: Pattimura Magister Law Review, Volume 4 Number 2, pages 167-179.
Nadilla Aini, et.al, 2026. Obstacles and Needs of Health Services for the Elderly in Present, Siti Rufaidah Journal, Volume 4 Number 1, pages 26-38.
Nasihuddin, Abdul Aziz, et.al., 2024. Pancasila Law Theory, Elvaretta Buana, Tasikmalaya.
Ningsih, Zilvia. 2020. Children's Obligations to Elderly Parents According to Law No. 1 of 1974, Scientific Paper, University of Mataram, pages 1-15.
Pertiwi, Nyimas Lidya Putri, et.al, 2021. Children's Behavior Towards Parental Care in Nursing Homes in a Review of Islamic Law (Case Study at the Srikandi Foundation Bandar Surabaya Central Lampung), Syakhsiyah: Journal of Islamic Family Law, Volume 1 Number 1, pages 72-90.
Prastyananda, Nirbaity, 2016. Household Neglect (Legal and Gender Studies), Muwazah Journal, Volume 8 Number 1, pages 74-97.
Pulungan, Sahmiar. 2011. Building Morality Through Religious Education, Al Hikmah Journal, Volume 8 Number 1, pages 9-24.
Qamarina, Nur. 2017, The Role of Orphanages in Carrying Out the Function of Substituting Foster Children in the UPTD of the Social Orphanage of Anak Harapan Samarinda City, eJournal of State Administration, Volume 5 Number 3, pages 6488-6501.
Romdhoni, Abdul Aziz, 2024. Filial to Parents in Islam, Values: Multidisciplinary Scientific Journal, Volume 1 Number 1, pages 53-60.
Saipudin, et.al., 2022. A Comparative Study of Islamic Law and Positive Law on the Obligation of Children to Provide for Parents, Al Gharra: Journal of Islamic Family Law, Volume 1 Number 2, pages 50-61.
Sari, Melia Putri Purnama, et.al. 2022. The Responsibility of Adult Child Maintenance to Elderly Parents, Journal of Ius Constituendum, Volume 7 Number 2, pages 293-306.
Sari, Ria Permana, 2025. Policy Strategies for Improving the Quality of Life of the Elderly Through Lifelong Social Protection, Syntax Literate: Indonesian Scientific Journal, Volume 10 Number 9, pages 7306-7324.
Writing, Action. 2023. Principles of Material Criminal Law in Indonesia, Nusa Cendana University Research Institute, Kupang.
Soekanto, Soerjono, et.al. 2015. Normative Law Research: A Brief Review, 17th edition, Raja Grafindo Persada, Jakarta.
By Yogi O'Neill, et.al. 2020. Child Support Rights to Parents in the Perspective of Positive Law and Hindu Law, Widya Kerta Journal of Hindu Religious Law, Volume 3 Number 2, pages 91-103.
Tuasikal, Muhammad Abduh, 2016. Providing for Indigent Parents, https://rumaysho.com/14668-menafkahi-orang-tua-yang-tidak-mampu.html, accessed on June 26, 2026, at 09.45 WIB.
Tuliyabu, Siti Nurmilawaty, et.al. 2024. Efforts to Fulfill Maintenance Rights for Abandoned Elderly Parents in the "Jannati" Elderly Griya Nursing Home, Democracy: Journal of Legal, Social and Political Science Research, Volume 1 Number 2, pages 85-95.
Widiyastuti, Y. Sari Murti, 2020. Principles of Civil Liability, Cahaya Atma Pustaka, Yogyakarta.
Jeremiah, Nova Lin, et.al, 2026. Domestic Neglect According to Indonesian Criminal Law (Case Study of Decision No. 159/PID. SUS/2021/PN. MAK), Journal of Lex Crimen, Volume 14 Number 5, pages 1-12.